Proving PBM ROI to Your CFO: A Guide for HR Leaders

As a head of HR, you're constantly balancing employee needs with budget realities. Your pharmacy benefits program likely represents a significant portion of your healthcare spend, but when your CFO asks about the return on investment, do you have clear, convincing data to share?

In this guide, we'll walk through how to effectively demonstrate the ROI of your pharmacy benefits program to finance leaders who want hard numbers, not just promises.

Why PBM Metrics Matter to Your CFO

CFOs speak the language of measurable results and financial impact. When discussing your pharmacy benefits, vague assurances of "competitive discounts" or "industry-leading rebates" won't suffice. Your finance team needs:

• Clear cost visibility: Exactly what you're spending per member per month

• Verifiable savings: Concrete evidence that cost-containment programs work

• Trend analysis: How costs compare year-over-year and against benchmarks

• Financial forecasting: Reliable data for budget planning

Without these metrics, your PBM investment appears as just another healthcare expense rather than a strategic program delivering measurable value.

The Problem with Traditional PBM Reporting

If you're working with a legacy PBM, you may find yourself struggling to extract meaningful financial data:

• Complexity by design: Reports filled with industry jargon and convoluted calculations

• Focus on discounts, not actual costs: High discount percentages may mask inflated base prices

• Limited access: Often requiring special requests or additional fees for detailed analysis

This reporting approach makes it nearly impossible to clearly articulate ROI to your finance team. When your CFO asks pointed questions about pharmacy spend, you need straightforward answers.

Four Key Metrics Your CFO Wants to See

When preparing to demonstrate PBM value to your finance team, focus on these four critical metrics:

1. Per Member Per Month (PMPM) Costs

This straightforward calculation shows the average monthly cost of prescription benefits per enrolled member:

PMPM = (Total Annual Pharmacy Costs / Number of Members) ÷ 12

Why your CFO cares: This metric provides a clear baseline for comparing costs across time periods, against industry benchmarks, and following program changes. It's the foundation of pharmacy benefit financial analysis.

2. Program-Specific Savings

Each cost-management program should deliver quantifiable savings. Your reporting should track:

• Savings from formulary management

• Utilization management program results

• Specialty medication cost containment

Why your CFO cares: These metrics show the direct financial impact of specific strategies, helping identify which programs deliver the best return and where to focus future investments.

3. Rebate Transparency

Rebates represent a significant portion of your pharmacy program's financial performance, but only if they're fully passed through to you.

Why your CFO cares: Finance leaders need verification that:

• All rebates are captured and credited to your account

• No hidden fees or revenue-sharing arrangements exist

• Rebate amounts are appropriate based on utilization

• Rebate credits are included in financial reporting 

4. Experience and Clinical Outcomes

While less direct than financial metrics, member experience and clinical outcomes have significant budget implications.

Why your CFO cares:

• Poor member experience leads to HR support costs and potential talent retention issues

• Medication adherence impacts overall healthcare costs and productivity

• Effective clinical programs prevent higher downstream medical expenses

How Modern PBMs Are Changing the Conversation

Today's innovative PBMs have transformed reporting from a cryptic quarterly exercise to a transparent, real-time resource:

• Real-time dashboards: Access to live data rather than retrospective reports

• User-friendly interfaces: Clear visualizations that don't require pharmacy expertise to interpret

• Customizable views: Finance-specific dashboards that focus on the metrics your CFO prioritizes

• Actionable insights: Recommendations based on data patterns, not just raw numbers

Proving ROI with SmithRx Partner Portal

The SmithRx Partner Portal provides HR leaders with the tools needed to clearly demonstrate PBM value to finance teams:

Accessing Key Financial Metrics

The “Reports” section of the Partner Portal is your gateway to self-service reporting. Once logged in, click “Go to Reporting” on the right hand side of the page. This will open up your reporting dashboard, which consists of 6 different categories of reporting, listed at the top of the page.

Overview

• Top menus allow you to navigate to PMPM reports, connect savings, pass-through rebates, top plan pay drivers and top Connect cases.

PMPM

• Month-by-month PMPM tracking

• Comparison to prior year

• Cost drivers affecting your PMPM

Connect 360

• Savings breakdowns by program type

• Top medications by cost and associated savings

• Program ROI calculations

• Projected annual savings based on current utilization

Pass-through Rebates

• Detailed rebate amounts by drug category

• Timeline of rebate applications to your account

• Verification of 100% pass-through with no hidden fees

• Quarterly and annual rebate summaries for financial reporting

Top Plan Pay Drivers

• Shows the top therapy areas by plan pay by total billed to plan and claim count

• Also displays the top drugs by plan cost, comparing last quarter to the previous

Top Connect Cases

• Shows the top connect cases by annualized savings based on 12 month projection

Creating CFO-Ready Reports

When preparing for financial review meetings, use the Partner Portal's reporting section to download all of your quarterly data, or create a custom report.

Quarterly Reporting

1. From the main menu, navigate to the "Reporting" page

2. Click the “Combined Reports” button at the top right side of the screen

Custom Reports

1. From the main menu, navigate to the “Reports” page

2. Here, you will see the 6 different reports available at the top of the page

3. Navigate to the report that you want to customize

4. On the top right, adjust the date range

5. Download your report by clicking on the three vertical buttons in the top right quarter

These reports automatically highlight key financial metrics, trend analysis, and actionable recommendations—all in the language your CFO understands.

‍

Having the ROI Conversation with Your CFO

Armed with data from your Partner Portal, you can now approach ROI discussions with confidence:

1. Start with the bottom line: Begin by showing overall PMPM trends and how they compare to benchmarks and previous years

2. Demonstrate program value: Show specific program savings and how they've contributed to cost containment

3. Provide verification: Share rebate tracking data to confirm all manufacturer rebates are properly credited

4. Connect to broader objectives: Link pharmacy program performance to organizational goals like employee satisfaction and productivity

5. Discuss future opportunities: Use predictive analytics to show projected savings from planned program enhancements

Beyond the Numbers: Strategic Partnership

The most valuable aspect of modern PBM reporting isn't just the data itself—it's the ability to transform that data into strategic action. With SmithRx, you gain a partner who helps you:

• Identify emerging cost drivers before they impact your budget

• Implement targeted interventions based on your specific utilization patterns

• Forecast pharmaceutical pipeline impacts on future budgets

• Develop multi-year strategies for sustainable cost management

Next Steps

Ready to change how you discuss pharmacy benefits with your finance team?

For current SmithRx clients:

• Contact your SmithRx Account Manager to request a demo of the Partner Portal for your group.

• Invite your finance team or relevant stakeholders to a meeting with your SmithRx Account Manager to discuss opportunities to maximize group savings.

For prospective clients:

• Contact the SmithRx sales team to learn more about this powerful tool and learn how we can help you deliver better value and outcomes.

With the right metrics and reporting tools, you can transform pharmacy benefits from a mysterious cost center to a transparent, strategic investment with clear and measurable returns.